The idea of making a black US Army bag is a good one because it looks more civilian and doesn't attract attention. However, the execution is far inferior to the original. The fabric is cotton, but not tightly woven, and is see-through. The stitching is sloppy, often crooked and asymmetrical. The inside edges are unfinished and will fray. The metal accessories are ordinary magnetic metal and will rust. I would like to buy a better-made version of this bag, even if it costs more.